Shock the Tote: The Greatest Upsets in Horse Racing — And How to Spot the Next One

Donerail shocks the 1913 Kentucky Derby.
Donerail shocks the 1913 Kentucky Derby.

Horse racing’s magic lives in the moments when the “impossible” happens: a 91‑1 shot threads the rail; a Triple Crown steamroller gets ambushed; a late addition storms home at 80‑1. This guide turns famous underdog wins into a playbook you can use today—complete with angles, examples, and bet‑building tips designed to help you profit the next time the Tote board goes haywire.

What Counts as an Upset (and Why It’s Your Edge)

In simple terms, an upset is when a horse with high odds—reflecting low public confidence—beats shorter‑priced rivals. Favorites win roughly one in three Thoroughbred races in North America, which means two‑thirds of the time the chalk doesn’t win. Your edge is not guessing. It’s building a repeatable process to identify mispriced horses where the crowd is underestimating pace dynamics, surface or distance changes, trainer intent, or track bias.


Hall‑of‑Fame Upsets (and What They Teach Us)

Donerail shocks the 1913 Kentucky Derby (91‑1)

Still the longest‑priced Kentucky Derby winner ever, Donerail saved ground, pounced late, and paid a record $184.90 on a $2 win ticket. Lesson: Inside trips and patient rides can turn outsiders into overlays—especially when the favorite faces pressure.

Jim Dandy topples Triple Crown hero Gallant Fox in the 1930 Travers (~100‑1)

On a muddy Saratoga track, Jim Dandy embraced the going while Gallant Fox got embroiled in a duel. He won by a big margin at colossal odds. Lesson: Weather and track condition can flip the script; some longshots move up in slop.

Arcangues detonates the 1993 Breeders’ Cup Classic (133‑1)

A French turf star many dismissed on U.S. dirt, Arcangues unleashed a furious stretch run to beat Bertrando—the biggest BC upset in history. Lesson: Beware underrated internationals and surface‑switchers with deep class.

Mine That Bird, 2009 Kentucky Derby (50‑1)

From last to a 6¾‑length romp, a rail‑skimming trip turned the Sunland‑based gelding into a legend. Lesson: Trip and rider can unlock hidden ability; watch for aggressive rail riders and ground‑saving tactics in large fields.

Sarava ends War Emblem’s Triple Crown bid in the 2002 Belmont (70‑1)

The favorite stumbled at the start; Sarava sat close and out‑stayed Medaglia d’Oro. Lesson: Gate reliability matters at 12 furlongs; when the favorite’s weapon is early speed, a poor break can rewrite everything.

Even the greatest can be vulnerable to pace nuances .
Even the greatest can be vulnerable to pace nuances.

“Upset” beats Man o’ War (1919 Sanford)

Yes, the horse was literally named Upset—handing the titan his only career defeat. Lesson: Even the greatest can be vulnerable to pace nuances and juvenile inconsistencies at Saratoga—the ‘Graveyard of Favorites.’

Onion over Secretariat in the 1973 Whitney

At Saratoga again, Secretariat met a fit, in‑form speed horse and wasn’t quite himself; Onion seized the day. The defeat was shocking because Secretariat was at the peak of his fame, having just won the Triple Crown in record-setting fashion, including his 31-length victory at the Belmont. Lesson: Form cycle and timing—catching a star off peak—can make a serious price live.

Rich Strike, 2022 Kentucky Derby (80‑1)

Entered from the also‑eligible list the day before, then sliced through late to post the second‑biggest Derby upset. Lesson: Late field changes and pace meltdowns in 20‑horse Derbies can create chaos—keep an eye on AE entries and deep closers when the pace looks hot.

Global stunners over jumps: Foinavon (1967 Grand National, 100‑1) & Norton’s Coin (1990 Cheltenham Gold Cup, 100‑1)

Over obstacles, race‑shape randomness and attrition amplify underdog chances. Lesson: In chaotic races, navigation and stamina can trump raw ability at big prices.


 

Form cycle and timing can catch a star off peak.
Form cycle and timing can catch a star off peak.

People Also Ask—Quick Answers You Can Use

·       What is the longest‑odds Kentucky Derby winner?

Donerail (1913) at 91‑1, still the record. Rich Strike (2022) ranks second at 80‑1.

·       What’s the biggest Breeders’ Cup upset?

Arcangues in the 1993 Classic at 133‑1.

·       How often do favorites win?

About one in three Thoroughbred races in North America—so value often lies away from the chalk.

·       Why do longshots win?

Misread pace, bias, form cycles, surface/distance changes, rider tactics, and field size shift real win probabilities away from public perception.


 

Angles to Find the Next Big Upset—Field Checklist

Use this as a pre‑race scoring sheet. If you can tick three or four boxes on a single horse at a big price, you have likely found value.

Angle

What to Look For

Pace Picture Favors the Price

Lone‑speed in a paceless race or a confirmed closer in a projected pace meltdown; confirm with recent pace figures and running styles of top choices.

Bias Match

Upgrade prices moving with the day’s bias (inside/front or outside/late); downgrade favorites moving against it.

Surface/Distance Switch

Turf‑to‑dirt, dirt‑to‑turf, sprint‑to‑route (or back) with pedigree hints and trainer success; upsets love new questions with hidden answers.

Trainer Intent & Form Cycle

Second‑off‑layoff, blinkers on/off, gelding, equipment tweaks, or a quiet prep into the target spot.

Class Relief or Subtle Class Rise

Dropping into softer waters helps; lightly raced improvers can leap forward versus over‑exposed chalk.

Rider Fit

Aggressive rail riders, gate specialists, or top locals on ‘unknown’ shippers can change outcomes.

Trip Potential

Inside posts in big fields save ground; tactical speed avoids traffic and sets up first run.

Workout & Health Signals

Pattern matters more than one fast time: steady spacing, improving finishes, and sharp gallop‑outs.

Under‑the‑Radar Numbers

Pedigree stamina for today’s distance and energy distribution profiles that suit the expected pace.

Toteboard vs. Morning‑Line Mismatch

If live horses float 2–3× above their morning line without new negatives, the public may be mispricing them.

 


 

A pace advantage can cause an upset.
A pace advantage can cause an upset.

Bankroll‑Smart Ways to Bet Longshots

·       Win/Place structure: Split stake 60% Win / 40% Place on bombs at 8‑1 to 20‑1; at 30‑1+, consider Win/Place/Show to smooth variance.

·       Exacta shield: Key your longshot over/under the most likely pace beneficiaries (one chalk + one mid‑price).

·       Three‑horse ‘value box’ (EX or TRI): Anchor your price with two logicals you don’t want to beat you.

·       Dutch between two live prices in the same race when both are overlays.

·       Cap fewer races deeply; demand value lines—if your fair line is 10‑1 and the tote offers 18‑1, you bet; otherwise, you pass.


 

More Classic Underdogs Worth Knowing (Quick Hits)

·       Giacomo (2005 Kentucky Derby, 50‑1): Ground‑saving, perfectly timed rally that detonated record exotics.

·       Country House (2019 Kentucky Derby, 65‑1 via DQ): Historic disqualification of Maximum Security elevated a huge price.

·       Foinavon (1967 Grand National, 100‑1): Navigational brilliance amid chaos; the fence was later named after him.


 

FAQs

1.       What’s the single biggest clue a longshot is live?

A pace advantage—lone‑speed or true closer in a meltdown—that the public hasn’t priced correctly, especially when it aligns with bias.

2.       Do upsets happen more in big fields?

Yes. Traffic, trip variance, and pace complexity grow with field size, widening outcomes and prices (see Derby shockers).

3.       Which surfaces produce more longshot winners?

Full‑field turf routes are fertile ground because trips and late pace matter more; sloppy dirt can also scramble results.

4.       Is it smarter to chase bombs or play safe?

Neither by default. Price‑based discipline—bet quality setups at overlay odds and skip underlays—wins over the long term.

5.       How should I manage bankroll around longshots?

Pre‑set unit sizes, avoid chasing, and use structured bets (Win/Place, exacta shields) to harness payoff while limiting drawdowns.

 


 

Final Thought: Turn History into Profit

Every upset above isn’t random—it’s a pattern you can recognize: pace, bias, trip, timing, and price. Build your race‑day routine around those five pillars and you’ll stop chasing bombs and start investing in overlays.


 

A Bias can cause and upset.
A Bias can cause and upset.

Related Articles: 

 


Post a Comment

Previous Post Next Post